Skip to main content

I'm looking at the various models but am stumped on what to focus on. Given the following information maybe you guys can recommend something? Smiler

- I've been BBQ'ing for a while (to me at least!) since around 1992.

- I like "Texas" style BBQ in that I cook dry smoked BBQ and never have boiled anything. I add wet glaze at the end but not during the effort. I'm in Arkansas by the way.

- I own a trailer based grill/smoker that uses charcoal/wood for the fuel (lump coal). I can cook 36 racks of baby-back ribs on the entire thing but usually cook only on half of it (I use the other half as the heat source) and do 18 racks at once.

- I own a Green Egg but primarily grill with it (and love it for that). I sometimes use the smoke plate for small situations but it's usually not worth the effort.

- I cook domestically but do BBQ for charities when requested (and I have time.) When I cook for my friends and family it can be for around 40 people. When I cook for charities it can be for around 400 people.

- I sometimes smoke 18 racks of ribs and 6+ pork butts at once but not always.

- I'm interested in a electric smoker but am concerned about how to get the "crust" or char I get from my current rig. Typically I char the meat over the heat and then move it to be smoked over several hours. I also add a glaze at the end for some of my BBQ and am concerned if the electric smoker can obtain the proper carmalization.

- I'd like to be able to BBQ for just my family of 4 (and do so economically.)

- I want to be able to smoke fish.

I'm looking at the FEC (the smallest one) but the $3700 price tag is going to be a hard sell for my wife. I also have looked at the AQ cooker but am concerned about it being too small?

Help would be appreciated, especially from those that own the units or competing ones. Smiler
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

As I was reading your description, I was thinking FEC 100. So you're right on the mark. I don't compete or market. But I am a very serious amatuer, who has smoked on many types of vessels. I smoke as many as 20 racks of babybacks or 16 spares several times a year (or sometimes 4-6 racks for myself that I cryovac and freeze)that I give away as gifts. I've got people begging for them!

3 years ago I stuggled for several months over the price and concerns with potential problems with the electronics/feeder.

3 years later, I can tell you. One of the best, if not the best, cooking equpment decisions I ever made. LOVE my FEC 100!
I've heard some people talk about their meat coming out with a rubbery texture instead of a nice crust. That or they end up having to grill the meat after its smoked to get the texture "right." Is that not a problem with the FEC100? Right now texture is my main concern. I guess I'm adverse to change. Wink
Gamer,

You have to look at which forums you're getting that from. The FE's are mainly in the FE forums only. The rest of the forums deal with the Electric CS's.

The Electrics do fine, they just have a VERY humid environment, by design, to help the newbie/average user. The smaller of the electrics only go to 250 and poultry like more than 275 to get a good texture.

The FE's do not and you will get a traditional taste/texture from them, as they burn 100% wood and the airflow is different. FE's can get very hot.

For your description, I'd go with an FE. If you can't afford the full on, look for them on sale, but when they go on sale, they're usually picked up quick for a reason.
quote:
Originally posted by SmokinOkie:
Gamer,

You have to look at which forums you're getting that from. The FE's are mainly in the FE forums only. The rest of the forums deal with the Electric CS's.

The Electrics do fine, they just have a VERY humid environment, by design, to help the newbie/average user. The smaller of the electrics only go to 250 and poultry like more than 275 to get a good texture.

The FE's do not and you will get a traditional taste/texture from them, as they burn 100% wood and the airflow is different. FE's can get very hot.

For your description, I'd go with an FE. If you can't afford the full on, look for them on sale, but when they go on sale, they're usually picked up quick for a reason.

Thanks for the note. I believe I was reading about the electric smokers and it took a while for me to see that the FE's use wood, which in reality what I am used to. Now to convince the wife. Wink
quote:
Originally posted by Gamer Outfit:
By the way, I ordered the FEC 100 today. I will keep you posted as to the results.

By the way, what's up with the main website? It is sloooooowwww. It took me literally 10 minutes to add 4 items to my cart.


I am sorry about this Gamer Outfit. We appreciate your business and we don't like it when things do not work right for our customers. Your time is important and no one likes to be kept waiting.

I am meeting with our web managers today and will mention this. Unfortunately, without more information these things are virtually impossible to track down. Was our web server getting a lot of traffic and consequently slowed down? Was it the customer's mail server? Was the internet just wild right then with everyone voting on some singer or dancer on one of those singing or dancing shows? We will do everything we can from our end to see that everyone has a good shopping experience!
Its the web server itself. I visit dozens of sites a day and usually can tell which ones are bandwidth starved. I also happen to be a programmer and game developer (hence the name).

It appears either your server is overloaded, your database back-end is overloaded, or your actual Internet pipeline is overloaded. Your store should be much more responsive. Send me an IM if you need help debugging the problem from my end.

Have a good day!

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×