Skip to main content

I did a brisket last week 12.5 lbs put it on at 5am ran at 250F for 7hrs (top shelf) then flipped it upside down on the third shelf bumped temp to 275 it was done by 2pm internal temp 203. It came out very moist and was great tasting but....
it had NO smoke flavor at all. not being an expert but, i think i could have tossed it in the oven and got the same thing. How can i get smoke flavor?

I checked the pit temps along the way and they where right on with the setting the thing just got done about 3 hrs ahead of schedule.

How am I screwing up?

Bernie Wurts
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

You can enhance the smoke flavor by going straight from the fridge to the cooker, without letting the meat get to room temp first. ( that's if your doing that?). Secondly you can start the cooker and then turn it down to smoke and open the door up without the unit warming up. Leave it on smoke for atleast 4 hours after you put your brisket in. Then turn it up and start cooking more. This will increase the smoke flavor in your bigger cuts of meat.
I am using an FE 100 and am the envey of my neighbors. I have no clue what brand of pellets the wood is hickory from the pellet master himself Mr. EDDY

I brisket gets a painted with mustard then a rub the night before. goes from fridge to smoker.

Can i start the smoker on "smoke" then shut the door or do i have to start at a higher setting and then bring down to smoke.

eddy you said at "least" four hours what would your recomend as ideal time?

one more thing eddy do you have pellets i'm out


Bernie
Big Orange, they are talking about the controller settings on the FE. The first setting is smoke which cycles the auger on for 15 seconds and off for 50 seconds. The cooker temperature will usually sit around 150 to 180 at that setting. This setting burns the pellets less efficiently so they generate more smoke. We usually start at that setting then go up on the temp during the cook.

Smoke ring occurs even with little to no smoke and is due to chemical reactions with nitrates (similar to curing meat). It doesn't represent how smokey the meat is. Go to our website and click on the "Classic BBQ" link. You will see a picture of a brisket done on the FE and you'll see the smoke ring.

With regards to "high dollar" cookers, there are many other cookers much more expensive than the FE. It has more working parts so it has more problems than a cooker with no moving parts. It is also much more consistent than other cookers and (arguably) more versatile than other cookers.

Pellets are 100% wood, no binders or fillers (like some charcoals have).

The difference in smoke flavor is how efficient the cooker burns the pellets. It is very efficient so you don't get as heavy a smoke flavor as wood burners. Most people prefer less smoke flavor (then again, some don't).

Hope that helps.
Hi.

Mr. Orange, your link seems to be broken.

And just a small point, this particular subject forum is titled FEC Owners Forum, so naturally it deals with FEC's. But, having said that, and admitting that I am new to this forum in general, there are some very nice and helpful people here. I can't believe that you would be here just to mock or devil the other members, so you must find some useful information and interesting points of view here. Can't recall ever reading anything about hitting the highroad just because someone was using a particular type of smoker.

I just happen to disagree with you on the pellets vs. wood. First off, pellets are wood. Second off, if you haven't used a pellet smoker you shouldn't dismiss it out of hand. Third, taste in food, particularly BBQ, is Subjective. You like lots of smoke, I don't. I want some, but I just don't want to burp it 6 hours later! I like a thick crust on my pizza you like a thin, so what, no one is wrong. If your smoker works for you and you like what it produces, well, I for one am happy for you. Atta Boy! (No matter how many Atta Boys you get it only takes one "OH S***" and they're gone!)

Don't get prickly because we want to use what we want to us. Perhaps you don't mean to sound so antagonistic, but you do. This is, in my opinion, a place to come if you need to fine tune your FEC smoking skills with fellow FEC users, or anyone with constructive input. I presume that if any of us wanted to be using wood from the "wood lot" we would have gone with a different smoker. You intimate that FEC users are "elitists" but, you are being a "wood pile" snob. Live and let live Mr. Orange.

Play nice, and PEACE!

Kate
Mr. Orange,

It's always interesting to get different points of view. I use and love the FE. I also have a WSM and a Lang84 I smoke with. I used to use a New Braufels offset. I grew up cooking with a split 55 gallon drum with the bottom half rusted out (just down the road from you in Louisiana). I don't think any of us would argue that you can get fantastic que with any type of cooker.

Each of them imparts a different flavor and each has its own advantages and disadvantages. Most of the time when I cook with logs (oak, hickory, cherry, apple here 'cause I can't get Pecan), I have to foil to avoid getting too much smoke flavor according to the folks I cook for. Your tastes are different which is fine.

As Kate said, this is the FE forum so that's what we usually talk about.

If you ever get up this far, I'd love to drink a beer (or sip whisky if you prefer), have a cigar and let you check out the FE. I'm sure any pellethead around you would extend the same offer. Likewise, I'd love to drink a beer and do some que with you when we're down that way if you're willing.

I'm trying to play nice, so don't delete me Smokin, I still haven't gotten over the last time Big Grin

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×