Skip to main content

Finally got the courage to smoke a brisket. It turned out that I was worrying for nothing.
Here are the details:

Found a 16.5 lb. packer cut brisket at Wal Mart for 98 cents a lb. It was not a choice-but rather a select grade. I figured I was beat before I got started-because of the size and the grade.

I almost cut it in half because of the size-but didn't.
I wanted to do the yellow mustard thing-but didn't have time to let it sit overnight. I figured this bad boy would be at least a 24 hr. smoke.

I combined the last of my c.s. rib rub with some Excaliber steak and roast rub, along with a shot of garlic powder. I then gave the brisket a double coat of rub.

With a little Houdini magic I folded the brisket onto one rack and slammed the door. Temp. was set at 225.

I also made up some beans and had them in a foil pan on a rack underneath.

After 10 hrs. the temp. was 179. At this time I opened the door and took out the beans.

At 14 hours meat temp. was 190. I'm now thinking something is wrong cause my cook time is less than an hour a lb. So I open the door and give this hunk of meat the fork test. Tines went in easily and pulled out easily in 3 places, plus juice really came out of the meat.

Okay,I'm thinking it's done-but decided to leave it in another hour. The last 45 minutes I cranked the temp. up to 250 degreess just to see if any more grease would release. Got some, but not much.

So after 15 hours in the Model 50 I took the brisket out,foiled and put in cooler. Temp of the meat was 192 degrees. After three hours in the cooler it was still to hotto handle with bare hands. I then set it on the cutting board for another half hour to rest.

I then sliced with an electric knife. The burnt ends were chopped up with a knife and added into container.
Some of the meat was pullable but most sliced very easily. Had to use paper towels ot mop up the juice so it didn't run off onto the floor.

The meat was very tender,juicy and very flavorful. I impressed myself,but give all the credit to my Cookshack.

So there you have it. It's done when it's done and this big hunk was done in less than an hour per lb.

Had to pitch the beans. They were way too smokey for my taste.

BTW I used maybe 6 oz. of hickory and 4 oz. of peach wood. Part of that was added when I took the beans out.


The meat is darn good without any sauce added to it. It is even tender right out of the fridge. Think I will go have another piece.....

Wink Wink
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Glad you had success. You can't always cook those beast with a set time/temp rule. You can only estimate.

There are burnt ends that come from the thinner pieces of the brisket overcooking and then there are the Kansas City "burnt ends" which typically is the fatter part of the brisket thrown back in (after separating from the flat) and giving it a double smoke. Chunk those babies up and eat them like popcorn.

Smokin'
quote:
Chunk those babies up and eat them like popcorn.



I need to go to Kansas City. I did the burnt ends number after finally securing a "choice" "packers cut" brisket. Whew, what a chore!

Smoked the whole number for 10-12 hrs; then cut off the "point" and threw it back into the pit. (That's a comment I collected from Tom! "Throw it back in the pit.")
4 more hours for the burnt ends (following Jamison and Jamison). Nirvana.

But still, I'd like to see how they do it in Kansas City.......where it is said this double-cook technique was invented.

[Hard for me to say that, seeing as how we invented BBQ in Florida.]

Cool
Glad your brisket turned out.

Brought a smile to my face. Having raised a few cattle in my life, if you got a 16.5 lb select grade brisket, then the cow it came from died of old age.

Buying choice grade will improve the product even more. If you can ever find it (without paying a small fortune), get some certified angus. The claim is that this choice grade meat has better flavor characteristics because of the way that this particular breed intersperses fat into the muscle. I don't know if all that science is true, but the very best briskets I have cooked have been certified angus.

Kudos to the cook that took a lower grade piece of meat and turned it into something wonderful. Looking forward to your next success story.
Hi...long-time reader first time responder.
I've always considered pork shoulder and ribs to be the only chunks of meat worthy of smoking but I'm beginning to broaden my horizons. In the past 6 months I've also tried goose and duck breasts (not even a hint of gaminess!), venison roast (again no gaminess with no outlandish preps done), buffalo roast, shrimp (OMG!) and turtle (never again). With siblings that have relocated in Texas, I had remained staunch in my stance against the lowlt brisket. Well this old dog decided to try one. A 14- pounder packer from Walmart set the stage. No extra trimming...no deckle removal...no rubs or brines or injections. It went in at 6 pm at 180 degrees with 3 small chunks of hickory (not that pallet scrap they call mesquite). The next morning I added a couple more small chunks of hickory. At 4 pm I turned the temp up to 225 for 2 hours. Took it out and let it set for 1/2 hour. I sliced it up best I could. The flat sliced fairly well but the point was so tender and juicy it was falling apart. Heaped it on buns with some of my homemade sauce and...well...I became a believer! Nothing short of an epiphany. I've had pb&j sandwiches that put up more of a fight than that brisket did. The flavor was better than what I could have ever hoped for. I've heard that briskets can be tricky but this was definitely a no-brainer with perfect results. I'm doing another one next week so I'll see if it was just a fluke. Maybe it was the Iowa corn-fed beef that did it instead of that scrawny stuff they call cattle in Texas. Ok...that last comment was for my sibs in Texas.

may the smoke be with you!

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×