Skip to main content

My 4.8 lb boneless pork butt smoked at 225 for 10 hours, with an additional hour at 250. I used my own rub, heavy on the cumin and hungarian paprika, light sprinkle of turbinado and I sauced once at 160. I did not foil during the cook, and followed suggestions not to fan out the meat but to cook it in a roast shape. Rested for 30 minutes in foil. I was a little worried that the nice looking bark would get soggy resting in foil after the cook, but thr bark was textbook, the pork pulled easily.
I know a lot of people let the butts rest in a cooler, but I chose to leave it in the smoker with the door ajar and this seemed to work well. Is there any reason not to do this (other than someone/something stealing my dinner?)
Robbo
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

What is the reason for saucing during the cook and also for having the door 'ajar' during the rest? The Smokette is a moist cooker and retains moisture from the meat throughout the cook. This moisture will escape when you open the door. You are also letting heat out when you open the door during a cook. There is no need for basting or 'saucing' during a cook in a Smokette. What temp did the meat reach after 225 for 10 hours and 250 for an hour?

I hope this helps. It is hard for alot of folks to transition from traditional methods and smokers to a CookShack.
Oh yea that does sound a little harsh for lack of a better word. Sorry.

Wheelz is right, if you are happy with the results, that is all that matters.

I hope I helped you understand the dynamics of this type of cooker along with my constructive criticism. It is a world apart from a wood or charcoal fire. I didn't mean to sound as if you did it all wrong. I am sure it ate very well. Just trying to help you make it easier on yourself.
quote:
Originally posted by Robbo:

I know a lot of people let the butts rest in a cooler, but I chose to leave it in the smoker with the door ajar and this seemed to work well. Is there any reason not to do this (other than someone/something stealing my dinner?)
Robbo


Food safety. In a cooler will lose temp slower than just sitting it in your smoker. I'd keep the door closed and monitor the temp and don't let it fall below 140
quote:
Originally posted by GLH:
Oh yea that does sound a little harsh for lack of a better word. Sorry.

Wheelz is right, if you are happy with the results, that is all that matters.

I hope I helped you understand the dynamics of this type of cooker along with my constructive criticism. It is a world apart from a wood or charcoal fire. I didn't mean to sound as if you did it all wrong. I am sure it ate very well. Just trying to help you make it easier on yourself.

Thanks for clarifying-no offense taken. I actually tries saucing during the smoke because I read someone's comment that it could help develop bark, and I also was guessing that adding some sauce to the top of the butt might slow moisture loss. I do plan to rry it without next time. Variations keep things interesting for me.
Regards,
Robbo

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×