Skip to main content

Here's what i'm planning for memorial weekend let me know if i'm correct. 25-1" ribeyes would like to marinate overnight and then smoke for a hour or so and then let guests cook to there desired doneness on the charcoal grill. Recommendations on type of marinade and how long to smoke at what temperature. Thanks
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Well,I don't know that I would want to change a nice flavored beef steak into a marinade flavor,but some folks do.

Some folks like something simple like a little wooster sauce for moisture,and a Montreal type steak seasoning.

Your marinade typically only penetrates about 3/8 inch,so just google steak marinades and use one that looks simple and the ingredients are inexpensive.

Some folks may run the smoker kinda cool-maybe 180º,to an internal of about 100º.

Tent them with foil and then cook fast and hot to desired doneness.

Hope this helps a little.
I am quickly loving my FEC, but for Rib eye's (My favorite cut) I will fall back to my XL Big Green Egg. I love a inch plus cut, rubbed with my favorite rub, a hot fire and a chunk of Hickory or Cherry in the fire. I am a rare to Med Rare guy.

Please let us know how the smoking turns out. Humm, I have some Rib Eye's food saved in the freezer, it might be "What's for dinner".

Best of luck
quote:
I am quickly loving my FEC, but for Rib eye's (My favorite cut) I will fall back to my XL Big Green Egg. I love a inch plus cut, rubbed with my favorite rub, a hot fire and a chunk of Hickory or Cherry in the fire. I am a rare to Med Rare guy.

I have to agree with you, i've never smoked a steak before just looking to add a little smoke flavor before grilling. Do most of you use a wet marinade or dry?
quote:
Originally posted by nichboy:
Here's what i'm planning for memorial weekend let me know if i'm correct. 25-1" ribeyes would like to marinate overnight and then smoke for a hour or so and then let guests cook to there desired doneness on the charcoal grill. Recommendations on type of marinade and how long to smoke at what temperature. Thanks


Why are so many people obsessed with marinating steaks? I have friends that look at me like I am crazy when I season with Kosher Salt and Fresh Ground Pepper and throw it on the grill! If you use good quality Choice or Prime meat that has been aged for at least 14 days you will get a tender, flavorful meal and you will actually taste the beef rather than Pineapple-Teriyaki, Soy-Citrus, Fire-Rubbed, Lime-Infused marinade of choice. If you want smoke flavor throw a handfull of soaked chips on your grill. Saves time and effort too!
I'm with Bacchus2b. I like my steak practically naked with a fistful of chips on the coals. I'll occasionally do woster & Montreal, but salt & pepper is best on a real steak, my opinion anyway. Big Grin

It's difficult for most folk to find 14-day aged steak. Personally, I prefer 21 days which is next to impossible to find. All my beef is grassfed and custom cut. The abattoir will usually do 14 days but 21 days is a rarity.

Smoked steak has been discussed several times if anyone cares to use the "find" feature.

Have fun!
Well,when Uncle Jimmy Carter decided to help the farmers' profits, and all of us live a leaner life,he moved all grades up one.

Thus, like Smokin's Mom,most cooks buy Zesty Italian Salad Dressing by the case to use on EVERYTHING. Big Grin

Our team included.

The gov't sold us on the merit of nice,friendly,vegetarian cows,that could be raised on weeds,crabgrass,and shredded newspaper and we would look like a supermodel. Roll Eyes

All that money saved from feeding nasty old corn-which we needed to make ethanol-or 13% protein creepfeed ,which we could feed to the deprived ,around the world,that hated us and could breed longer and out populate us.

The ungraded[that is usually pounded out and sold as 50 lb blocks of lousy meat to make burgers at the stockyard]became select.


Thus ,the select our parents grew up with, became choice.

The percentage of better choice,moved up to CAB,or a better corporate marketing program,and overall choice could be as high as 50%.

To benefit the consumer,who could no longer cook,and make the meat look better,longer on display,allowed the packing houses to add up to 18% salt water.

Of course,at full meat price.

The grocery ran promotions on this stuff,because their distribution center shipped it,and the marketing dept ran the ads.

The meat dept,hired min wage folks,that laid the prepackaged cuts out on the racks.

The folks that sought out the better choice,or even prime,PETA came and set fire to your lawn,and wrote nasty letters to your church.

Now,I posted above about a slather of wooster and some salt,pepper,garlic,and onion,and then I'd toss it on some white hot lump charcoal at 700*,until it quit squirming.

Now,some folks have enough complications in their life,and it is easier to eat tofu-whatever that is.

I hear you can marinade it with ketchup?

Just my $0.02,so I'll get outa here,before someone accuses me of makin' a Smokin'Okie post.
Last edited by tom
Like I said, I am a rub guy. Sometimes as simple as S&P, but I really like Plowboy's products. So, Bovine for my steaks.

Hot and fast, a chuck of hickory or cherry and cook to a cool 125 (I like rare). Off, tent, cut enjoy.

I appreciate the grading post, but I let me eye do the judging. I look for a nice marble and I buy in bulk. Whole Ribeye's, cut at home to my size and foodsave. I have about 20 in the freezer right now. Just to be sure I have enough, but I will buy more if the price is right.
I don't smoke my steaks but give this a try..these are to die for!

• 1/2 cup olive oil
• 1/4 cup Worcestershire sauce
• 6 tablespoons soy sauce
• 1/4 cup minced garlic
• 1/2 medium onion, chopped
• 2 tablespoons salt (Just a dash of SALT!!!)
• 1 tablespoon pepper
• 1 tablespoon crushed dried rosemary
• 3 tablespoons steak seasoning (Only 2)
• 3 tablespoons steak sauce (e.g. A-1)
• 4 (10 ounce) Delmonico (rib-eye) steaks
quote:
Originally posted by Tom:
Well,when Uncle Jimmy Carter decided to help the farmers' profits, and all of us live a leaner life,he moved all grades up one.

Thus, like Smokin's Mom,most cooks buy Zesty Italian Salad Dressing by the case to use on EVERYTHING. Big Grin

Our team included.

The gov't sold us on the merit of nice,friendly,vegetarian cows,that could be raised on weeds,crabgrass,and shredded newspaper and we would look like a supermodel. Roll Eyes

All that money saved from feeding nasty old corn-which we needed to make ethanol-or 13% protein creepfeed ,which we could feed to the deprived ,around the world,that hated us and could breed longer and out populate us.

The ungraded[that is usually pounded out and sold as 50 lb blocks of lousy meat to make burgers at the stockyard]became select.


Thus ,the select our parents grew up with, became choice.

The percentage of better choice,moved up to CAB,or a better corporate marketing program,and overall choice could be as high as 50%.

To benefit the consumer,who could no longer cook,and make the meat look better,longer on display,allowed the packing houses to add up to 18% salt water.

Of course,at full meat price.

The grocery ran promotions on this stuff,because their distribution center shipped it,and the marketing dept ran the ads.

The meat dept,hired min wage folks,that laid the prepackaged cuts out on the racks.

The folks that sought out the better choice,or even prime,PETA came and set fire to your lawn,and wrote nasty letters to your church.

Now,I posted above about a slather of wooster and some salt,pepper,garlic,and onion,and then I'd toss it on some white hot lump charcoal at 700*,until it quit squirming.

Now,some folks have enough complications in their life,and it is easier to eat tofu-whatever that is.

I hear you can marinade it with ketchup?

Just my $0.02,so I'll get outa here,before someone accuses me of makin' a Smokin'Okie post.


I am going to print this in a fancy font and hang it on my wall! This is priceless.
I just ordered one today from Cookshack. I cant wait to try it out. When i get it within a couple weeks and try it out, I will let everyone know.
quote:
Originally posted by SmokinOkie:
For me, I only smoke steaks when I have to do them for a contest. The rest of the time it's S&P and a good hot grill.

Maybe I'll get one of the new CS Charbroiler's to try out

quote:
Originally posted by nutrientcobra:
I just ordered one today from Cookshack. I cant wait to try it out. When i get it within a couple weeks and try it out, I will let everyone know.
quote:
Originally posted by SmokinOkie:
For me, I only smoke steaks when I have to do them for a contest. The rest of the time it's S&P and a good hot grill.

Maybe I'll get one of the new CS Charbroiler's to try out




nutrientcobra , i ordered my about two months ago, and we love it i cook on it evey day just rememeber to season the grill with vegitable oil and heat it up and let it cool, i did this about a couple of times before i cooked on it the first time, Stuart gave me this hint before i used it and if you are buying this for your backyard, i use a can of spray carnaoil to caot the grills after they cool so they dont rust.. just a hint, have fun
Last edited by Former Member

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×