Skip to main content

Just to clarify, when you folks talk about cooking times, am I correct in assuming you
start with a cold oven and meat right out of
the fridge?

My experience:

I just got my Smokette last week. I tried a couple of slabs of STL ribs, following the recipe in the book that came with the oven:
rib rub overnight, then right from fridge into cold oven, set temp to 225 and cook for about 4 hours over 2 ounces of hickory. I hadn't read any of the forum comments (oops!) so didn't know to try the bone-tear test. The ribs were delicious but just a tad too chewy. The slabs were well-trimmed and, though I didn't weigh them, I'd guess that they weren't more than 3lbs each. Also, I didn't open the door at all during cooking. Maybe I should've allowed the meat to come to room temp first?

Chris
Original Post
Welcome Meat.

I always start with mine cold. Here's why. One theory (you decide) is that meat stops absorbing smoke after it hits 140 (something to do with meat fibers closing, etc).

So, if you start with it cold, it has longer to absorb the smoke.

Chewy ribs = underdone.

In my experience, a 1/2 pound difference in rib slab weights can be from 45 min to an hour more.

My #1 suggestion. Keep a log (tell them you haven't heard that one before Forum gang). That way, you'll be able to build on your own experiences. I have a MS Word or Excel spreadsheet that some are using.

Definitely weigh your slabs. You'll see a big difference in ribs in the future after you cook a few and you'll get more consistent results.

You learned a valuable lesson, using the CS recipes or what you read in the forum...as 'ole Smokin says, It's done when it's done meaning there are so many little variances that you can't cook Q by an exact time.

For ribs, it's the bone twist.
For brisket, it's the fork twist.

Welcome to the group.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×