Skip to main content

Got a 13.28 LB of "First Street" butcher packed, un-trimmed Brisket from "Smart and Final" and seasoned it with Kosher salt, cracked pepper, garlic power and onion power. Set it overnight in the frig.

Did not trim any fat off this first one to see how it would turn-out.

Placed it, fat side up in AmerQue on second shelf at 5 PM, with 4 OZ of Hickory and 2 chunks of charcoal (for smoke rings). Set smoker to 225 degrees and inserted meat probe in largest portion of "Flat" (just short of the "point") set temp to 190 degrees.

19 hours later it reached 190 degrees. Opened door for the first time to inspect results. Brisket felt like a big piece of jello and looked great, as far as texture. (Would have included a picture but had trouble adding it)

Wrapped it in foil and placed it into a paper lined cooler for two hours till ready for lunch.

Cut brisket, starting at one corner of the flat, due to grain running 90 degrees the other way, into ½" slices, served right away and they looked great. Peaces could easily be cut with a fork or just picked up at one end and have it break in half. Meat was somewhat firm when cutting but very tender.

Only problem keeping from doing another brisket is: meat was tender but somewhat DRY. People were asking for more (reduced down beef stock, onion and seasoning) dipping sauce I made earlier.

Is this typical for them to be that tender but be dry at the same time? Maybe try another manufacture?

Attachments

Images (1)
  • brisket_1
Last edited {1}
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Could be overcooked,to the fall apart stage,and be dry.

Starting with choice, is hopefully going to have more internal marbling,and more moisture.

Choice might extend up in quality as much as another rough 30% of the graded meats,until you get to prime.

Each level,hopefully gets better.

Did the meat probe go thru the flat like butter?

Did you check a couple places with a good instaread,to verify temps?[Just for future reference,since temp doesn't equate to tender.]

Did you check the AQ probe for accuracy?

How quick did you serve the meat,after slicing?

Instantly?

Maybe we can help a little,with these answered.
Tom, thanks for the help,


I was suspect from the start with that brisker. Sales person told me it was choice. I asked where on the package it was marked that way. He said that supplier always supplies choice meat. I still am suspect cause all the other meat was marked "select" in the refer reach-ins by the same packer.

Regarding the AQ probe: It fell right out of the brisket. When I touched the product in various places, it was soft (like a sponge) at the point and the flat had a resistance of pushing on foam rubber. Also felt like a cooked pulled-pork-but.

Did not check with an instant read on any part of the brisket.

Only cut slices when every body was ready. Cut slices only sat on a serving plate for five minutes prior to being on someone's plate.

When cutting up the point. It was plenty moist, but too fatty to serve. Only some pieces could be pulled from the fat and was served over sliced bread.

Maybe I should of stopped it at 180 * and check it out. I that point I could of probed it with an instant read in a few places, fork-checked. Made a plan of action on how to get the required results with possibly foiling for additional hour?
Last edited by Former Member
Be sure and get choice next time. To check doneness, poke with your therm probe. It should feel like it is going into butter. When done, wrap in 2 layers of HD foil, then towels, then into as small a cooler as possible. I have had them still too hot to handle after 8 hours. Seperate the point from the finished flat and put the point back into the smoker on 300*F (AmeriQue) until it gets up to 210*F internal. Always slice the flat across the grain. If the slices fall apart, slice thicker. When the point is real close to the boiling point of water (212*F), bring it inside, let it rest unwrapped for maybe 30 minutes, then chop it up, first 1 direction then crosswise. I use the edge of a metal spatula.

Hope this helps.

Keep experimenting. You are getting close.

Cool
Last edited by Former Member
Like GLH said.

The point may well take at least 210*

Choice should say it on the cryovac,or check the packing case.

Here is just one quick table of a method of grading.

1: Relationship Between Marbling Score, Intramuscular Fat, and Quality Grade a


Marbling Score Percent
Intramuscular Fat/SE
Quality Grade b

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Slightly Abundant 8.96 / .5 Low Prime
Moderate 7.14 / .2 High Choice
Modest 7.02 / .15 Average Choice
Small 5.21 / .1 Low Choice
Slight 3.76 / .1 Select
Traces 2.54 / .2 Standard

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



I'd try cooking some choice and keeping good notes,before I'd give up and start foiling.

If you have not verified the accuracy of the AQ probe,it could be misreading and overcooking the flat.

There are comp cooks that cook briskets year round,and don't get better than you did.

Quality of the raw meat,WILL make a huge difference.
Last edited by tom

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×