Skip to main content

Four and three-quarter pounds of New Zealand boneless leg of lamb in the freezer and three guest. I figured after trimming ALL the fat and silver skin there would be four and half pounds left. The following is the coating used for a marinade:

1 whole regular size garlic bulb roasted for 45 minutes at 350 degrees in the oven.
2 tablespoons of chopped fresh rosemary.
Two chopped shallots.
20 drops of Tabasco sauce.
½ cup olive oil.
2 teaspoons cracked pepper.
1 teaspoon kosher salt.
1 tablespoon Cookshack Rib Rub.
4 strips thick bacon.

Four hours in the refrigerator in a ziplock bag. After removing from the marinade (most of it stuck to the lamb) it was wrapped with the bacon and tied with string. The bacon was used to replace some of the missing fat. The AmeriQue was set at 250 degrees and the probe installed in the middle of the lamb at a good angle so most of the probe was inserted. The thermometer probe was set to 140 degrees for a finish temperature. We used 3.5 oz of hickory in the new firebox.

Four hours later the Amerique went into the standby mode and because the lamb was ready before dinner it was placed in foil, towels and a plastic cooler. The smell was so wonderful it was all I could do to control myself. I meant to take pictures with the new digital camera, but when the company arrived and it was time to have some red wine and slice the lamb I got carried away. I would say over a half pound of the lamb went for taste test, but we had a good time with just the wine and lamb pieces and bacon.

Now, what is all this about. It's about having friends to eat the best lamb they ever had and each wanting to know more about how it was cooked. All three of our visiting friends said they had never experienced such wonderful lamb. I have made a few learning failures with my CS55 and AmeriQue, but this was not one of them. Big Grin

Smokemullet
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Re: Mutton (8/22/2003 8:40:58 AM by Tom-Fl)

I don't know about good,as it is an acquired taste-but I can tell you how they do it back home.

We don't see many mutton roasts here,but around an eight pound shoulder roast from a yearling lamb is close.

Marinate in refrigerator,at least overnight.
Around Daviess County[Owensboro]they use about 1/2 gal. of water,one cup of worchestershire,one cup of vinegar,and 1/2 cup of your pork rub.

Use half and save the rest to mop with.

Just south,in Christian County,they just mop every 15-20 minutes with what amounts to a Carolina vinegar sauce with some extra lemon juice thrown in.

Drain well and use your pork rub,like you would on a butt.
Cook at about 220º to at least 170º internal,foil and let rest.

Around there,they serve it sliced,coarse shredded,and chopped.

Hope this helps some.

Tom
I used to have a friend who grew up in Owensboro and would bring mutton back every time he went home to visit. It was fantastic stuff and the sauce that he would bring with it was probably the best part. It seemed like it was mostly made up of a lot of the drippings from cooking the mutton. Very watery like a mop. I once flew him down (from MI) to Owensboro and we went to this little hole-in-the-wall place to get the mutton but I doubt if I could ever find it again. Frowner
In one of the posts above, somemeone mentioned "aquired taste." Personally, I can't handle the taste of lamb but the Mrs was raised on it. I always felt it was a greasy, oily meat. With the CS being such a moist smoker I can't imagine it being any different other than the smoked flavor. Am I the only odd-ball out there who doesn't care for lamb? Maybe I need to give it another try.

Any suggestions? Doesn't necessairly have to be smoked. TIA!
The "hole in the wall" could be Shady Rest,Old Hickory Pit,George's,where the locals eat.

Mutton can have a strong taste and can require a strong sauce.

Mutton drippings probably weren't part of the mix.

Moonlite has a red sauce,and a vodka based sauce,that is pretty hot.

There are sauces that have a lot of wooster,red pepper,and vinegar.

Pork is still the main meat in w Ky,and an assortment of thin red sauces abound in the region.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×