Skip to main content

Greetings gang!

I want to throw this out to get some ideas from those of you that have experienced or solved this issue.

Most of you know we cook with two FE's on the back of our trailer. We only fire up one on Friday. We cook two butts on the top shelf and a brisket (big) on each of the next two shelves, fat side down. My theory is that the butts will baste the brisket below, and that brisket will baste the next one. Well, that works fine, but the bark on the briskets is very bad. In fact, some cooks it can be accidently scraped off if we're not careful. We foil the briskets when they look good, which is usually at about 170 degrees. Our brisket rub has very little sugar in it. The butts have awesome bark. Although we us a different rub, it also has very little sugar. I have given up spraying anything during the cook. I thought that caused the problem. While I see no difference in the moisture of the product, spraying is not what is giving me the bad bark issue.

We've considered doing things different in two ways. One, we thought about moving the butts down two shelves and cooking the briskets on the top two shelves. Our concern is that now the bark on the butts will be bad. Two, we're thinking about firing up the second FE on Friday and cooking the butts in one and briskets in the other. That seems wasteful because I don't know what I'd do with any more than the same two butts we cook, so one cooker would have just two butts in it while the other cooker would have the two briskets. A side note: We used to battle a moisture issue with the briskets. Cooking this way has solved that, but created this new problem.

I don't know if I've given you enough info, but I'd sure appreciate your input. Thnx!

Rod
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Friday was the first time I cooked butts and briskets separate on 2 FEs. Mainly I did it because I wanted different smoke flavor on them and I cooked 3 of each at Bentonville (not on purpose!). But, one thing I liked is only using the middle 2 shelves for both of them rather than juggling stuff around. Is your bark on the brisket kinda crackly? Maybe rub is too thick or hasn't set on the brisket long enough?

Nice seeing you both this weekend. That rum cake was fabulous!
Candy,

I can take no credit for the rum cake. That was all Sheri.

No, my bark is more like a paste than a bark. altough you really can't tell it until it's too late. I accidently scraped the flat side of my brisket on the grate getting it removed from the pit to foil, and a fist size piece of bark came right off. Made me sick!

Rod
Russ,

Putting it on pretty heavy. Doing it at least two hours before we put it on to cook. I foil by looks instead of temp. It looks good. This problem is something new for me. I'm going to have to sit in a quiet place to think about what I've changed in my brisket cooking that I'm not even aware of. I don't realize the bark isn't set well until I grab it to foil it. That's when the trouble begins.

Sheri and I have all discussed all kinds of things to try, problem is, we'll be trying it at a contest this weekend that's paying the brisket winner $1K. Not a good place to play around.

Rod
Rodney, one of the things I have done that has helped a little when I see that my bark has not "set" is to take some of my rub that I have run through a coffeemill to get it very fine and then sprinkle it on after I remove it from the foil or if it has not set, and I find that the salt in the rubs absorbs some of the excess moisture and then I let it cook another 1/2 hour or so to get it to "set" I also do not know since I have not cooked with the FEC enough, but you might try cranking the heat to 240ish to see if it will evacuate the moisture some from the rub and get it to set quicker.

Hope these ideas help

Christian
Scott,

We have had some success with the bark issue. Based on the comments here, we added some sugar to our rub. That, coupled with foiling them even later or not at all in the cook, has solved the issue. Putting the butts on the bottom shelf was not the answer as it effected the bark on them and I simply can't have that.

We are still working on dialing that brisket in.

Rod

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×