Skip to main content

I smoked a 5lb beef round yesterday, thinking it would be easily pulled like a pork butt but instead it needed to be sliced. Also the meat was a tad dry. No juice flowing from the meat. I dont remember if it was a top or bottom round (or what the difference is).
Maybe the grain pattern for this cut of meat does'nt lend it self to be pulled? Maybe I cooked it wrong? Heres how I cooked it:

I marinated it overnight in two cans of Dr. Pepper. Took it from the fridge and put it on a plate with a little rub ( Turbinado sugar,lowreys,garlic powder). I let it sit for approx 45 mins while getting ready for work.
I put it in the Cookshack with the fat cap untrimmed and on top. Set the dial to 225 degrees and went to work. Came home and the internal temp was 170. I took it out at 185. I let it rest on the counter for about 20 mins before diving in. The meat was good with just a little smoke flavor and I thought it had a fair amount of bark which had a good flavor as well.
I just figured it would pull but maybe not. Any ideas would be appreciated.
Thanks
Eric
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Stubby,

Beef wont pull at 185. With out foiling with some liquid, your round roast probably would never pull. It would dry out before it got tender enough to pull. The fat and collagen ratio isn't the same in a beef round as it is in a pork shoulder.

Though I've never done a beef round, I think my 1st try would be to smoke it to about 160-65 then wrap in foil with some beef broth or other juice of choice and put it back in unitl it hits somewhere between 195-205.

Just a thought.
GeiyserQ has posted some good info considering he's form Ohio Big Grin

Do take it to a higher temp for pulling (consider chopping). Adding broth and foiling at 160˚ will help. Round may be just a tad too lean. If you want to pull or chop and don't want to do brisket, consider going with a cut from the chuck section - more fat and stringy.

GeiyserQ -- I spent my first 28 years of life in Michigan, not far from Ann Arbor so my blood still runs Blue. Big Grin See ya at the Horseshoe November 18, on the Blue side of course!

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×