I smoked my first deer shoulder yesterday, and it turned out really well. Used a variation of what GLH posted earlier, only went a step further. I rubbed the shoulder with olive oil, then liberally applied Bad Byron's Butt Rub to the outside. Then I injected olive oil with garlic salt mixed in it into the muscles. Hung the shoulder from a rib hook and used 2 oz Hickory chunk at 225 degrees. The end result was smoky and moist (but not greasy).
Original Post