Skip to main content

Hi all,
A thought crossed my mind, but a bit of background first: I've owned a number of rudimentary smokers and wish to upgrade to a smoker that will give me consistent results while reducing some of my effort (Unfortunately, I don't have a lot of spare time to babysit my smoker). I've been researching commercially-available smokers for the past few weeks. I intend to do a mix of cold smoking as well as hot smoking. Naturally, I'd like to get that flexibility in one unit. My other criteria is that I don't want to jump through a lot of hoops in order to keep my cold smoking temperatures down. All of the units in my price range ($1,000) seem to be geared more towards hot smoking, since the heating element also generates the smoke and is located in the main chamber. My question is: Has anyone cut a hole in the side of their Cookshack and installed an external smoke generator? (I know....there goes the warranty!) In theory, it would seem that one would get the best of both worlds. In my humble opinion, from reading posts here and elsewhere on the net, there is a need for something like this. I'm not willing to wait for a manufacturer to design one, so I'm toying with buying a Model 55 and getting out the hole saw. I hope this gets me some feedback. Any thoughts? Thanks!
Paul
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Perhaps you're looking at this backward: Why not use the Cookshack as the smoke generator and use one of your other smokers as the smoke box? You could easily pipe smoke from the top of the CS into something else, even running it thru some sort of chiller if you wanted to get really fancy.
I went to Homedepot and bought a 1/2" threaded gas pipe fitting and a flexable hose able to hold higher heat like 100 - 200 degrees(eletrical dept hase these).

I unscrewed the fitting that vents the smoke. put the top fitting from the outside on the inside, screwed the new fitting on the top(outside) and I now have a hose to direct the smoke. It did not seem to reduce the flow of smoke any but the hose is not more than 30" and I did not bent it more than 45o and kept it above the smoker.

I paid about $5 for all the pieces.

Could this be bad? sure but I am not smoking anything inside. What could be whr worst if I did have food inside? Well, more moisture and less reheating of the oven and more smoke inside longer.

Could that be bad? Not sure. Times that I was use to may change a little. Anyone have thoughts?
quote:
Originally posted by dmaclaren:
[qb]I went to Homedepot and bought a 1/2" threaded gas pipe fitting and a flexable hose able to hold higher heat like 100 - 200 degrees(eletrical dept hase these).

I unscrewed the fitting that vents the smoke. put the top fitting from the outside on the inside, screwed the new fitting on the top(outside) and I now have a hose to direct the smoke. It did not seem to reduce the flow of smoke any but the hose is not more than 30" and I did not bent it more than 45o and kept it above the smoker.

I paid about $5 for all the pieces.

Could this be bad? sure but I am not smoking anything inside. What could be whr worst if I did have food inside? Well, more moisture and less reheating of the oven and more smoke inside longer.

Could that be bad? Not sure. Times that I was use to may change a little. Anyone have thoughts?[/qb]

uummm beer
Instead of connecting directly to the hole in the top of the CS, you should have created a space of about 2" between the hole and the start of your pipe. Most folks have discussed using a setup like a gas water heater with an upside down funnel device that is 2" above the CS and connect that to the pipe carrying the smoke. This creates a draft to bring the smoke out of the CS - the CS operates better this way.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×