Skip to main content

Hello every one,
Please help me make a critical decision before I screw up another great piece of meat.
I am curing a ham and a Boston butt in a "Morton tenderquick" brine which should be ready to smoke in a few days in a water smoker.
Should I put liquid in the water pan or leave it empty?
I seem to remember reading somewhere that some folks put rocks, or sand in the water pan instead of liquid?
Your answer to my questions would be most appreciated.
Thank you very much for your help, and Happy Thanksgiving to all.
Mike
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Howdy Cap10mike,

The sand is to work as a heat sink,as your water pan does.

I have never heard of rocks,unless it was big sand.

The sand with foil over the pan ,may help with cleanup.

I haven't used sand in mine,but talk to a bunch that do.

If you are familiar with your cooker, using water,that would be my choice.

I'm all for innovation,but I still feel that Weber knew what they were doing for all around cooking.

Now,if you are wanting to run high temps,you would leave the pan out.

Unless you are broiling a ham slice,you probably don't need them.

Hope this helps a little.
With a WSM if you are going to use sand the fire needs to small at the beginning or the pit temps are easier to lose to the high side.
I use water sometimes and sand others both work well, for this cook the Minion Method for fire control will make your life easier
(even if I say so myself).
Jim
I am going to try that John Folse recipe also Tom, just what I needed to make Gumbo with the left over turkey.
Will let you know about my "Buckboard bacon" SmokinOkie, I will have it in the smoker early in the Morning.
Hmm... better tell the wife to get ready to scramble lots of eggs to go with the bacon for thanksgiving Big Grin
Just discovered Jim Minion's article about firing up the Weber Smoker...Super, and now I know why I have screwed up so badly in the past...
Thanks to all for your help, never knew I could have so much fun BBQing and smoking.
Happy turkey day friends.
Mike

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×