You know me, I've gotten pretty opinionated about judging.
After reading some of the comments on this site (link below), it scares me that judges make the various comments they do.
I think one of you first posted it, but I just got time to check out some actual photos and comments.
Reading those comments tells me judges have just taken too much personal opinion and turned it into fact with their scores. Look at the photos and click on "comments" to see what CBJ's say. Uh, like "it looks dry so I'm scoring it down for appearance? I don't remember dryness being a criteria for appearance (it's in tenderness)
Personally, I wish the judges would put comments every single time they score, to all teams and they had to prove their score. If I got some of those comments I would probably be visiting the reps.
The worrisome part is just like what happened when Judges started posting about chicken skin, this kind of site will help "teach" BBQ judges what others do. It was never judged for "bite through skin" no it's the defacto standard (so you have to scrape the skin, use meat glue, debone the chieken ---aaarrrchhh)
Thats just not BBQ to me.