Skip to main content

Hi, I'm a new member but have been browsing a few pellet grill/smoker forums for a while. I currently own a six rack Bradley smoker, I've enjoyed it but am looking upgrade for several reasons. I did have my mind made up that I wanted an AmeriQue, but now I'm leaning towards a pellet grill/smoker.
Unfortunately I don't think I want to buy each of them right now so I have to decide on one. One thing I want to get away from is the need for the expensive wood "pucks", but going to needing wood pellets may not be a huge improvement, and I think you get more smoke flavor from the AQ. On the other hand I like the idea of being able to do some things at higher temps, and grill steaks now and then. Any advise?
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Mostly due the traditional stuff. Pork butts, brisket, chicken. I've done sausage and jerky, cheese, nuts along with various other things. One of the things I want is more capacity. A couple of times a year I'll do big meetings/parties and have to smoke meat for 100+ people, usually brisket, pulled pork and chicken.
Based on the large amounts of food you'll need from time to time, I'd suggest the FEC100 (pellet smoker) or the SM160 (electric smoker)

Cookshack states the FEC max load limits as
100 lbs. pork butts, 80 lbs. brisket, 60 lbs. ribs, or 24 chickens per load.

Neither of those are suitable for hi temp searing/grilling but either one will provide consistantly excellent BBQ.

Pros: the FEC will come up to temp faster and has a higher top end temp.
Cons: pellets are more expensive vs chunk wood but even so, pellet consumption in the 225 - 250 range is just over 1/2 lb @ hr.

I've owned both units and prefer the FEC100.

Bottom line, if large amounts of food are a necessity, go with the FEC100 and save the grilling for a traditional charcoal or gas fired grill. Of course, Cookshack also produces commercial grade charbroilers in 3 sizes...if money is no object Smiler

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×