Skip to main content

Tasted pretty dang good, but still room for improvement.

It was a 6.5lb bone-in butt, 225 for 13 hours (when temps ranged between 190 and 199), with a bit of mustard and then simple S&P based rub. I used 3.5oz apple and 3.5 oz hickory.

I guess my questions are the following:

1. Is the fat cap usually never fully rendered? The bark on the cap was good but underneath not fully rendered. Do most people remove that when pulling? (remove and munch on i'm sure)

2. Are there usually pockets and pieces of fat and cartilage that don't fully render out?

3. Are there usually small pieces (like the corners or any protrusions) that simply get dried/smoked out because of their small size? The bark and dried meat isn't bad when pulling, but nothing I'd want to come across in a sammie.

4. Am I over thinking this?


P.S. I'm trying to attach a pic (for the first time) so if the rest of this looks bad or like a whole lot of fail, that's why...

Attachments

Images (1)
  • firstbutt
Last edited {1}
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Good job!

1...I trim my fat cap before smoking, gives me more bark. Lots of folks do what you did.

2...YES

3....Yes, resting in foil will soften the bark, if you don't like it like this.

4...No, it is up to you and your experience to find the product that you and your family enjoys. No more having to eat what other folks like, good notes on your smoke will help you remember how to achieve the product you like.
1. depends on how much fat there is, the ones I see usually are okay with no trimming.
2. yes, and true with any PB. That's why it is best to hand pull so any undesirables can be eliminated.
3. If there are loose hanging pieces it is best to truss. The outer edges will get very well done.
4. 6.5 lbs. is a fairly small PB and 2 hrs/lb is at the long end of the timing range. Try checking for tenderness around 193-195 internal temp; just probe with the temp probe- if it penetrates with little resistance the meat is done. Experiment with higher temps (240-260) to get the amount of bark you like.
Last edited by tnq
1. I leave the fat cap on. When ready to process, 95% of it winds up in the garbage can.

2. Yes. Once you separate the larger muscles, you'll find wads of fatty tissue which you can just slide apart from the muscle.

3. Bone-in butts: trim away the nubs. Boneless: tie the butt together as best as possible. The "jerky-ish" meat (unless rock hard/burnt) will soften up once finishing sauce is applied...assuming you use one.

4. Heck no! Sharing observations is how we all continue to learn and develop.

Thanks for the post and the pic.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×