Skip to main content

Smoked 25lbs of pork butt for a tailgate party next Sunday. Looking for advice on the best way to reheat it at the tailgate party. I want to make sure I don't dry it out too bad when I put it in the pan on the grill. was thinking of putting a little water in a pan and then putting the pork in a separate pan on top so it's essentially steaming it. Any other ideas? I feel like direct heat will make it tough.
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Funny. I smoked 26 lbs of pork butt for a barbecue the day after my son's wedding. Since we were busy with the rehearsal dinner, followed by the wedding the following evening, I had to smoke and pull the butts 3 days early and reheat.

I did exactly as MaxQue suggests instead we reheated the already pulled pork in a Nesco Roaster. Smokin's Finishing Sauce was key. Kept the pulled pork moist. People raved about the pulled pork...key being the smoke flavoring and the finishing sauce keeping the meat moist IMHO.

Given the choice of Carolina Tangy Sauce, Sweet Baby Rays, and Smokin's sauce to add to their sandwiches, most chose Smokin's and loved it. Of course, I suggested they might enjoy his sauce, but others tried it after hearing the raves from those before them. Some also tried Carolina style sandwiches (Carolina Tangy sauce and cole slaw on the pulled pork) just to try something totally differnet. Enjoyed those too. Sweet Baby Rays was hardly touched.
Last edited by pags
Oh. And if you make Smokin's Finishing sauce, make a triple batch for 25 lbs. You'll use it to moisten/hold the pork, add it while reheating the meat and as a finishing sauce to sandwiches. I had 3 plastic squirt bottles after preparing it (great for applying to sandwiches) and only had 1/2 bottle left after the barbecue. Great stuff. Perfectly compliments the sandwich.
Last edited by pags
I have taken a cooked butt and then pulled it, then placed it in a 2 1/2 gal zip lock bag and cooled. I had place the butts in foil to finish, and i took the liquid fron the foil and added it to the bags to keep moist.

To reheat, I have placed it in boiling water. I have used a turkey fryer and a 5 gal aluminum pot. I have done this with meals up to 90 people. Also did with brisket and ad very good results for both.

RandyE

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×