Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I agree with Tom. I usually do my lamb in my
Weber Kettle, indirect heat but assume I am cooking at about 350. I usually throw on some chunks and soaked chips in a foil pouch and I get plenty of smokey flavor. I like my lamb medium rare to medium so usually take it off at about 145, let it rest and slice it. I like the crispy ends the higher heat imparts as well. I am not sure that a leg of lamb will due well at low and slow as it is not a cut that will render like pork shoulder or chuck.
I've had good results doing bone-in leg of lamb in my model 50. It can also be cooked bone-out, rolled and tied, in which case it can be stuffed.

Coat with olive oil and brown well, either on a grill or stovetop.

Rub with S&P and some rosemary (optional. I like it a lot).

Smoke at 250 F until about 140 F internal in the thickest part.

My last one was 4.5 pounds and took 2:25 to hit 140 F.
Dundee,
I've done quite a few legs. On a Cookshack Smokette or 50 Series, if you do low and slow, I'd set the thermostat at 180 and take it to an internal of 150 - 152 (my wife doesn't like it rare). I usually buy boneless legs from Sams Club, which are 1/2 lb to 1 lb larger than the size you listed. My Model 55 seems to take about 7 hrs to get to the above temps on 2nd rack from the top. With your 3 1/2 lb'er, if you use a remote thermometer and keep your door closed, you should probably be done in 6 hrs. If you're a few degrees short of your target temp and everyone is stomping their feet to eat, it isn't against the law to give it a crank up to 250 to bump it up the last few degrees. Let the lamb rest 15 before cutting, or your going to have a huge pool of juice.
I hope that helps.

A simple rub of Tones Rosemary & Garlic, a little garlic/rosemary/red wine injection (optional), and a hollandaise sauce over the sliced lamb makes one fine entree. Try it sometime.

Paul

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×