Skip to main content

well I cooked my brisket until the polder read 195 degrees and the flat was tough. Put back in until the 12 hour time limit, polder read 210. Just like always...tender. Anyone explain whats going on? Everyone else says when they cook to 190 it's tender. Polder is brand new and used instant read and it was the same temp.
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Mornin',barbqr....You said you checked other places in the flat,to be sure you weren't in a fat pocket?....Although some don't like to,I have good success going to the foil/towels/cooler for at least an hour....If that was a packer trim,I either separate the point and throw back in the pit to 205� or leave the whole thing in and take to 200�+....Yes,sometimes I have to slice the flat a little thicker-but I can't recall any complaints. Wink Hope this helps. Smiler ....To tag onto Mike,if I don't have a meat fork handy,I stick my probe in several places....Even a toothpick works pretty well,once you have a feel for it.
Wink
Barbqer, Please check my post of the other day about using a fork to test your brisket. It's not ~always~ done at any given temp...just usually done.

Some questions come to mind: Was this a packer cut brisket with full fat cap? Was it Choice grade? Did you open your CS door during the cooking (other than at 195)? If so, how many times? Is your thermometer calibrated?

Regards, Mike

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×